Now available: The Expert Record, the Standard for expert witnesses using AI. Where to buy

The Expert RecordThe standard for expert witnesses using AI

AI in the Courtroom · Judges, courts and AI

Quanta Logistics v. Commissioner of Customs (Import-I)

Quanta Logistics told the Bombay High Court that a customs adjudication order relied on two nonexistent Supreme Court judgments and appeared to be drafted with AI. The customs authority did not defend the order. By consent, the court set it aside on October 30 and sent the matter back for a fresh decision within eight weeks.

Primary document readCustoms order quashed by consent and remanded for a fresh order October 30, 2026

What happened

Quanta Logistics Pvt. Ltd., a company with its registered office in Chennai, was the subject of an Order-in-Original dated August 11, 2026, issued by the Commissioner of Customs (Import-I) at the New Custom House in Mumbai. An Order-in-Original is the first-instance decision of a customs adjudicating officer. It is an administrative ruling, written by a government official who acts in a judicial capacity.

Quanta Logistics challenged the order in Writ Petition No. 5093 of 2026. Its case was that the decision had been written with the help of artificial intelligence and without independent application of mind. As its example, the company pointed to two judgments of the Supreme Court of India on which the Commissioner relied. According to the petition, neither judgment appears in any law report or database, and the citations looked like AI hallucinations. On September 1 the company wrote to the Commissioner asking for copies of the two judgments. The judgment records that the copies were never provided.

What the court did

The matter came before Justices M. S. Karnik and Sandesh D. Patil, and Justice Patil wrote the four-page judgment. Counsel for Quanta Logistics relied on the Supreme Court's September decision in Vijay Ghanshyam Gadiya v. Union of India, 2026 INSC 947, and the High Court set out three paragraphs of it. Those paragraphs in turn quote Pooja Ramesh Singh on decisions that rest on fabricated precedent, and they mention the Supreme Court's draft regulations on AI in courts.

The customs authority did not contest the point. Its counsel told the court that the order could be quashed and the matter sent back for a fresh order. By consent of both parties, the court set aside the order of August 11. It directed Quanta Logistics to appear before the Commissioner on November 5, 2026 at 11:00 a.m., and it directed that the proceedings be concluded within eight weeks of that date. The writ petition was then disposed of.

The limits of the judgment matter. The High Court made no finding of its own that AI was used, did not name the two judgments, and did not rule on who within the customs office drafted it. It recorded the allegation, the unanswered request for copies, and the concession. It imposed no costs and directed no inquiry into the officer.

Where it stands

The Quanta Logistics order is final as a disposal of the writ petition. The fresh adjudication was due to begin on November 5 and to finish within eight weeks, which places the deadline at the end of December. Neither the fresh order nor any departmental step concerning the original author was located as of November 16, 2026. The judgment does not say whether the same Commissioner or a different officer will decide the matter again. In Gadiya, by comparison, the Supreme Court sent the case to another officer.

The obligation it engaged

Quanta Logistics engages Clause 3 of the Standard, independent authority. The clause is written for experts, but the conduct is the same when a decision-maker does it: an authority entered a formal document without anyone confirming that the authority exists. The request of September 1 is the test the clause describes. Asked to produce the two judgments, the author could not, and the decision did not survive.

Clause 8, disclosure, is the second clause. The adjudication was undone less by the allegation than by the silence that followed it. A professional who can answer a request for sources on the day it arrives is in a different position from one who cannot answer at all.

The matter also shows how quickly a remedy becomes routine. Gadiya was decided on September 2, 2026. Within two months a litigant in a different forum cited it, the government conceded, and a consent order followed in four pages. For an expert whose report is challenged on the same ground, the comparable outcome is exclusion without a contested hearing, because retaining counsel will concede a point that cannot be defended.

Sources

What could not be confirmed

AI use was the petitioner's allegation; the High Court made no finding on it, and the customs authority conceded that the order could be set aside without explaining how it was written. The two judgments are not named in the judgment and were not identified. The Order-in-Original of August 11, 2026 and the letter of September 1, 2026 were not seen. The fresh order and any action concerning the original author were not located as of November 16, 2026. The judgment was read as hosted by the database, not on the High Court's website.

About this entry

This entry was checked against the primary document listed in the sources. The entry for Quanta Logistics v. Commissioner of Customs records conduct and what the tribunal did. It does not characterize a holding and it is not legal advice. Last checked November 16, 2026. More matters like this one are collected under the matters involving judges. If something here is out of date, write to [email protected].

Top