Now available: The Expert Record, the Standard for expert witnesses using AI. Where to buy

The Expert RecordThe standard for expert witnesses using AI

AI in the Courtroom · Fabricated citations and facts in filings

In re A.S., R.S.-1, and L.S. (W. Va.)

In re A.S. is a parental rights appeal that the parents won. The Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia vacated the termination order on November 12, 2026. In a footnote it recorded that the parents' brief contained a fabricated syllabus point and fictional quotations, cited the state's ethics opinion on AI, and referred the matter to the Office of Disciplinary Counsel.

Primary document readTermination order vacated and remanded on the merits; brief referred to the Office of Disciplinary Counsel November 12, 2026

What happened

In re A.S., R.S.-1, and L.S., No. 25-425, is an abuse and neglect case from the Circuit Court of Brooke County. The opinion uses initials because the case involves children. Three children were removed from their home in the spring of 2023. After an initial disposition that left the parents' rights in place, the guardian ad litem moved to modify the disposition. On May 27, 2025 the circuit court granted that motion and terminated the parental rights of both parents.

The parents appealed and raised seven assignments of error, all concerning what happened after the initial disposition. They argued that they did not receive adequate notice of the later proceedings and that the termination did not follow the procedures state law requires.

Their brief had a second problem. In footnote 12, the court states that its review was "hindered by the inaccurate citations to case law, statutes, and rules" in the brief, and that these included a fabricated syllabus point and fictional quotations. In West Virginia a syllabus point is the court's own numbered statement of the law that an opinion establishes, so a fabricated syllabus point attributes to the state's highest court a rule it never announced.

What the court did

On the merits the parents prevailed. Justice Kirkpatrick's opinion finds that the circuit court in effect excluded the parents from the post-dispositional proceedings and then terminated their rights without the required procedures. In re A.S. vacates the May 27, 2025 order and remands with directions. The mandate issued the same day.

The footnote handles the brief separately. The court observed that other courts have treated similar anomalies as indicative of generative AI. It did not find that AI was used here. It pointed the bar to Legal Ethics Opinion 24-01, issued by the West Virginia Lawyer Disciplinary Board on June 14, 2024, which states that lawyers must make sure work product produced by AI is accurate and complete and must supervise those who help them. It listed sanctions that other appellate courts have imposed for similar briefs, from fee awards to dismissal of the appeal. It said the court does not reject the use of technology in the profession.

Then, citing its own practice, the court referred the matter to the Office of Disciplinary Counsel for review. It imposed no monetary sanction and did not strike the brief.

Where it stands

In re A.S. is back in the circuit court for further proceedings on disposition. The referral is to the office that investigates lawyer conduct in West Virginia, and no outcome was located as of November 16, 2026. Each parent had separate counsel, and the opinion refers to a single brief for both without saying who wrote it. This record does not name counsel for that reason.

The obligation it engaged

In re A.S. engages Clause 3 of the Standard, independent authority, and it removes a common excuse. The clients were right. The trial court had made a reversible error, and the appellate court found it despite the brief. The citations were fabricated all the same, and the referral followed all the same. A sound conclusion does not excuse an unsound route to it.

That is the point the Standard's governing test makes for experts. An opinion is measured by whether a competent examiner, working from the primary sources, could reproduce the result. An expert whose conclusion happens to be correct, but whose cited studies, quotations or figures cannot be found, has not met the test, and a tribunal may say so in the same decision that accepts the conclusion.

Clause 4, checkability before adoption, is the second clause. A quotation attributed to a court is among the easiest outputs to check, because the opinion either contains the words or it does not. The court here had to do that checking itself, in a case about whether two parents would keep their children.

Sources

What could not be confirmed

The court did not find that AI was used and identified no system. The opinion does not say which counsel prepared the petitioners' brief. Legal Ethics Opinion 24-01 was not opened; its content is taken from the court's quotation. The brief itself, proceedings on remand, and the outcome of the referral were not located as of November 16, 2026. The opinion was read as extracted text from the copy hosted by the database; the passages on AI were read in full and the merits discussion in part.

About this entry

This entry was checked against the primary document listed in the sources. The entry for In re A.S., R.S.-1, and L.S. records conduct and what the tribunal did. It does not characterize a holding and it is not legal advice. Last checked November 16, 2026. More matters like this one are collected under the fabricated-authority matters. If something here is out of date, write to [email protected].

Top