Now available: The Expert Record, the Standard for expert witnesses using AI. Where to buy

The Expert RecordThe standard for expert witnesses using AI

AI in the Courtroom · Fabricated citations and facts in filings

Farhat v. Cutera, Inc.

In Farhat v. Cutera, defense counsel used the AI drafting tool Legora for a first draft, corrected its citations in Westlaw, and then filed the uncorrected version by mistake. A Northern District of California magistrate judge discharged his show-cause order on October 28, 2026, admonished counsel, and disregarded both the bad and the replacement authorities.

Primary document readShow-cause order discharged; no sanction; counsel admonished; challenged and replacement authorities disregarded October 28, 2026

What happened

Farhat v. Cutera, Inc., No. 26-cv-05674, is a civil action in the Northern District of California. On September 29, 2026, Cutera moved to dismiss the first and second causes of action in the plaintiff's first amended complaint. When Magistrate Judge Thomas S. Hixson reviewed the motion, the court could not locate certain cases it cited. The order states that the apparent inaccuracies raised a concern that the motion contained fabricated or unreliable authorities, possibly from generative AI.

On October 22 the court ordered Cutera's counsel to show cause by declaration. The order had four parts. Counsel had to identify, by page and line, every statement, quotation or citation that was inaccurate, fabricated, misleading or unsupported. Counsel had to explain how each item entered the filing, including whether a generative AI or other automated tool was used. Counsel had to describe the verification done before filing. And counsel had to supply corrections with accurate citations. The declaration had to rest on counsel's personal review of the authorities.

Counsel answered two days before the deadline. Her declaration acknowledged using Legora, a generative AI drafting tool marketed to law firms, for the initial draft. She stated that she then checked the cited authorities in Westlaw, found citation errors, and sent a corrected draft to her assistant. An earlier, uncorrected version was converted to PDF and filed instead, and she did not catch the difference when she reviewed the final PDF. She identified the inaccurate citations, gave corrections, and attached a redline comparing the filed motion with the corrected draft.

What the court did

On October 28, 2026 the court discharged the order to show cause. Citing counsel's explanation, her acknowledgment of the errors and her corrections, it declined to impose sanctions "at this time." It admonished counsel that responsibility for the accuracy of a filing stays with counsel, that the final document must be reviewed before filing, and that this is so regardless of the use of AI or delegation to staff. It warned that further filings with fabricated authorities or materially inaccurate citations may draw sanctions under Rule 11.

The Farhat v. Cutera order then dealt with the motion itself. The plaintiff's opposition had not noticed the citation errors, and Cutera's reply did not rely on the challenged cases. The court said it would disregard the challenged authorities, and it would also not consider the replacement authorities offered in the declaration. No further briefing was allowed on the point.

Where it stands

The show-cause proceeding in Farhat v. Cutera is closed without a sanction. The motion to dismiss remained pending when the order issued, and a ruling on it was not located as of November 16, 2026. The order does not say how many citations were wrong, and it does not name counsel's firm.

The obligation it engaged

Farhat v. Cutera is unusual in this record because the verification was actually done. Counsel checked the output against Westlaw and found the errors, which is what Clause 3 of the Standard, independent authority, requires. The failure came afterward, at the point where a checked document and an unchecked one sat side by side and the wrong one went out. The court's instruction addresses that gap directly: review the final document, the one being filed.

Clause 7, contemporaneous record, explains why the matter ended with an admonishment. Counsel could show the corrected draft, the transmission to her assistant, and a redline between the two versions. That record let her answer a four-part order in five days, and the court credited the explanation. A lawyer or an expert without the record would have had only an assertion.

Two consequences deserve an expert's attention. First, the corrections did not rescue the argument: the court refused to consider the replacement authorities, so the client lost the benefit of those citations entirely. Second, version control is part of verification. An expert who verifies a draft report and then signs an earlier export has delivered an unverified report, and the reader has no way to tell the difference.

Sources

What could not be confirmed

Counsel's declaration (ECF No. 26), its redline exhibit, the show-cause order (ECF No. 25) and the motion to dismiss (ECF No. 17) were not opened; their contents are taken from the discharging order. The number of inaccurate citations and whether any cited case was wholly nonexistent are not stated in the order. The description of Legora as marketed to law firms is this record's own and does not come from the order. The ruling on the motion to dismiss was not located as of November 16, 2026.

About this entry

This entry was checked against the primary document listed in the sources. The entry for Farhat v. Cutera, Inc. records conduct and what the tribunal did. It does not characterize a holding and it is not legal advice. Last checked November 16, 2026. More matters like this one are collected under the fabricated-authority matters. If something here is out of date, write to [email protected].

Top