Now available: The Expert Record, the Standard for expert witnesses using AI. Buy on Amazon

The Expert RecordThe standard for expert witnesses using AI

AI in the Courtroom · Judges, courts and AI

Jackson Federation of Teachers v. Fitch (Judge Wingate)

Judge Henry Wingate replaced a temporary restraining order that named parties not in the case and quoted language not in the statute. He later told the Senate a law clerk had used Perplexity. On October 22, 2026 the 5th Circuit vacated his preliminary injunction and directed that the case be reassigned.

Primary document readOrder replaced with corrected version; preliminary injunction vacated on appeal and case ordered reassigned to a different district judge July 23, 2025

What happened

Teachers, students and advocacy groups sued in Jackson Federation of Teachers v. Fitch, No. 3:25-cv-00417, to challenge Mississippi's ban on diversity, equity and inclusion programs in public schools and universities. On July 20, 2025, Judge Henry T. Wingate entered a temporary restraining order blocking the law.

Mississippi Today reported that the order listed as parties organizations that were not in the case, including the Mississippi Library Association and Delta Sigma Theta Sorority Inc. It also contained quotations that did not appear in the complaint or in the legislation, and it cited a 1974 case that appeared not to exist. The Attorney General's office moved to clarify or correct the order, and the plaintiffs did not oppose.

What the court did

Judge Wingate replaced the order with a corrected version, which he dated July 20, and the original was removed from the public docket. According to the ABA Journal, he initially described the problems as clerical errors.

In a letter to Senator Chuck Grassley dated October 21, 2025, Judge Wingate stated that a law clerk had used Perplexity "as a foundational drafting assistant to synthesize publicly available information on the docket," and that the July 20 order was an early draft that should not have been docketed. He wrote: "The root cause of the errors identified in Defendant's unopposed motion to clarify/correct was a lapse in human oversight." He reported that drafts now receive independent review by a second law clerk, that every cited case is printed from Westlaw and attached to the final draft, and that the errant order was preserved under records retention rules. His letter gives July 23, 2025 as the date of the corrected order.

Where it stands

Judge Wingate later entered a preliminary injunction, and Mississippi appealed to the 5th Circuit, No. 25-60496. The State asked the court both to vacate the injunction and to reassign the case to a different district judge.

On August 21, 2026, before argument, the panel issued its own request at docket entry 101: "At oral argument, the attorneys should be prepared to address whether, especially in light of the use of AI by the district court, this matter should be sua sponte assigned to a different district judge." That is the court raising reassignment on its own motion, distinct from the State's request, and it is the first instance located of a federal court of appeals putting a district judge's AI use to the parties as a reassignment question.

At oral argument on August 31, 2026, before Judges Jerry Smith, Catharina Haynes and Kurt Engelhardt, Deputy Solicitor General Anthony M. Shults argued that the injunction "relied on the legal reasoning in the flawed TRO, which we think is very concerning." Judge Smith asked counsel defending the injunction, "Don't you think that's a pretty serious matter?"

Update, October 30, 2026. The 5th Circuit decided the appeal in Jackson Federation of Teachers v. Fitch on October 22, 2026, in a published opinion by Judge Smith (Document 111-1). It vacated the preliminary injunction against H.B. 1193 and ordered: "The Chief Judge of the Southern District of Mississippi is DIRECTED to assign this case to a different district judge for all further proceedings." Judge Haynes wrote a short concurrence joining only that last paragraph.

The opinion opens: "The proceedings in the district court were a botch job, to say the least." It records that the "corrected" TRO, incorporated into the preliminary injunction, "still contained hallucinated information (namely, a citation to a purported Fourth Circuit case, ‘Cousins v. School Bd. of City of Norfolk,’ that does not exist)." It also states: "The district court—or perhaps, being charitable, its AI agent—ignored and manipulated governing law, apparently to satisfy a policy agenda," and "This district judge carelessly exercised his Article III power by issuing sloppy edicts based on falsehoods and fabrications." Which judge now has Jackson Federation of Teachers v. Fitch had not been located as of October 30, 2026.

The obligation it engaged

The use described in the judge's letter is a system asked to summarize a record. Its output then became the draft of a court order. That engaged Clause 2 of the Expert Record Standard, non-delegation, and Clause 3, independent authority. Parties, quotations and statutory text entered the order without being compared with the docket and the statute they purported to describe. The remedial steps the judge reported, a second reviewer and a printed copy of every case attached to the draft, are a working form of Clause 4: nothing is adopted until it has been checked against its source.

The appeal shows a second consequence. Once a system's error appears in a signed document, the other side may argue that the later work built on it is tainted as well. An expert whose early draft rested on unverified output faces the same argument at deposition.

Sources

What could not be confirmed

The original July 20, 2025 order was not opened; its contents are taken from Mississippi Today. The exact date of the preliminary injunction was not confirmed from the docket. The ABA Journal article date is approximate (published the day after the argument). Reporting described the argument as held on Monday; August 31, 2026 was a Monday. The 5th Circuit opinion of October 22, 2026 was read in full; whether the case has been reassigned, and to whom, was not located as of October 30, 2026.

About this entry

This entry was checked against the primary document listed in the sources. The entry for Jackson Federation of Teachers v. Fitch records conduct and what the tribunal did. It does not characterize a holding and it is not legal advice. Last checked October 30, 2026. More matters like this one are collected under the matters involving judges. If something here is out of date, write to [email protected].

Top