Now available: The Expert Record, the Standard for expert witnesses using AI. Where to buy

The Expert RecordThe standard for expert witnesses using AI

AI in the Courtroom · Fabricated citations and facts in filings

Gill v. Everyday Dose, Inc.

In Gill v. Everyday Dose, a brief with two nonexistent cases and five false quotations passed through three lawyers. The District of Delaware found all three violated Rule 11. It fined the two out-of-state lawyers $3,000 each and sent the order to their licensing authorities. Delaware counsel, who signed the brief but took remedial steps, was not sanctioned.

Primary document read$3,000 Rule 11 sanction on each of two attorneys; order served on their licensing authorities; contempt facts certified as to one; no sanction on Delaware counsel November 9, 2026

What happened

Gill v. Everyday Dose, Inc., C.A. No. 24-1359, is a breach-of-contract action filed in the District of Delaware on December 11, 2024. Two out-of-state attorneys, Charles Slamowitz and Zack G. Sharpe, IV, were admitted pro hac vice for the plaintiffs in February 2025. Joseph S. Naylor became the plaintiffs' Delaware counsel the following month. On May 5, 2025, the plaintiffs opposed a partial motion to dismiss. Mr. Naylor signed and filed the answering brief.

On December 11, 2025 the court ordered all three lawyers to show cause under Rule 11. The order identified two citations to cases that do not exist and five citations whose parentheticals quoted language that does not appear in the cited case. It also required each lawyer to state whether, and how, AI was used.

The responses conflicted. Mr. Naylor said he has never used AI for court filings and received the brief on the morning it was due. Mr. Slamowitz said Mr. Sharpe wrote the original draft. Mr. Sharpe acknowledged using AI for early outlines that contained AI-generated errors, said he had told Mr. Slamowitz to make sure the references were correct, and later submitted what he called a fully accurate draft. The court found that this draft also contained hallucinated authority. Mr. Sharpe did not attend the show-cause hearing on February 5, 2026, after the court denied his request to be excused. At the hearing Mr. Slamowitz admitted that a staff member at his firm used AI to revise the brief, and that he used AI to draft his own response to the show-cause order.

What the court did

The Gill v. Everyday Dose order finds that all three lawyers violated Rule 11(b)(2) by submitting a brief containing AI-hallucinated authority. It then treats them differently.

The court declined to sanction Mr. Naylor. It was persuaded that the fabricated authority did not originate with him or his firm. It noted his apology and the steps he took without prompting: he reported himself to his firm's management, revised his retention agreement to address AI, wrote an AI policy for the firm, and described the episode at a firm-wide meeting. The order still records that he signed and filed the brief and was not without fault.

The court imposed a $3,000 sanction on Mr. Slamowitz and directed the Clerk to send the order to his licensing authority. It found his answers about AI evasive and stated that any testimony that he did not use AI on the brief, or allow staff to do so, was "not credible." It imposed a $3,000 sanction on Mr. Sharpe, directed the Clerk to send the order to the attorney licensing authority in New York, and required him to attach the order to any future pro hac vice motion in the district. The court had already certified facts for contempt proceedings against him over the missed hearing and his repeated unprompted submissions.

Where it stands

The sanctions in Gill v. Everyday Dose total $6,000. The AI Hallucination Cases database dates the order November 9, 2026. Payment, the contempt proceedings docketed at D.I. 76, any objection to the order, and any action by a licensing authority were not located as of November 16, 2026. The order does not identify the AI system used.

The obligation it engaged

Gill v. Everyday Dose engages Clause 2 of the Standard, non-delegation, more plainly than most matters in this record. Each lawyer described the brief as someone else's work: an outline handed off, a draft received, a document signed on the due date. The court's answer was that the certification belongs to everyone who presents the paper. For an expert the parallel is a report assembled by an assistant, a testifying colleague or a litigation support vendor. The signature adopts all of it.

Clause 8, disclosure, explains the different outcomes. The court asked one direct question about AI use. The lawyer who answered it plainly and changed his practice was not sanctioned. The two who deflected were, and the court's credibility finding now travels with the order to their licensing authorities.

Clause 7, contemporaneous record, is the third clause. A year after the filing, three lawyers could not establish who introduced the fabricated cases, and the court had to resolve the question on credibility. A dated record of which system was used, by whom, and what was checked would have answered it in a page.

Sources

What could not be confirmed

Pages 1 through 14 of the 15-page order were read as extracted text. The text of the final page, which completes the Conclusion and carries the date and signature, could not be extracted, so the order's date is taken from the database and the signing judge is not stated here; the case number suffix indicates a magistrate judge. The licensing authority to which the order was sent for Mr. Slamowitz, the show-cause filings, the hearing transcript (D.I. 75) and the contempt certification (D.I. 76) were not opened. Payment, any objection, and any licensing action were not located as of November 16, 2026.

About this entry

This entry was checked against the primary document listed in the sources. The entry for Gill v. Everyday Dose, Inc. records conduct and what the tribunal did. It does not characterize a holding and it is not legal advice. Last checked November 16, 2026. More matters like this one are collected under hallucinated citations and facts. If something here is out of date, write to [email protected].

Top